Pinball
Pinball for Sale – Where to Find the Best Deals on New & Used Machines in 2025
Feb
Thinking About Buying a Pinball Machine? Here’s What You Need to Know
If you’re here, you’re either a die-hard pinball fan, a collector looking for your next machine, or someone who just decided their game room needs a pinball machine. Either way, I get it.
Finding the right pinball for sale isn’t as easy as scrolling Amazon and clicking “Add to Cart.”
- Prices on pinball machines vary wildly (from a few hundred bucks to $20,000+)
- Not all pinball machines for sale are created equal
- Some sellers are straight-up scammers
So if you’re looking for pinball for sale and want to get the best deal on a new or used pinball machine, you’re in the right place.
Let’s break down:
- New vs. used pinball machines – which one is better for you?
- Where to find pinball for sale at the best price (and avoid scams)
- The top pinball machines in 2025 worth your money
- How to maintain your machine and keep it valuable
New vs. Used Pinball Machines – Which One Should You Buy?
Buying a New Pinball Machine: The Pros & Cons
There’s nothing quite like unboxing a brand-new pinball machine for sale—no wear, no repairs needed, and that fresh-out-the-box shine. But before you rush in, let’s talk about the pros and cons of buying a new pinball machine.
Pros of Buying a New Pinball Machine:
- No wear and tear – Brand new means problem-free, at least for a while.
- Manufacturer warranty – Peace of mind in case anything goes wrong.
- Latest technology – LED screens, interactive features, and even internet-connected games.
Cons of Buying New:
- Expensive. Entry-level machines start at $6,000, and premium models can hit $12,000+.
- Depreciation. Like a new car, the second you unbox it, it loses value.
Buying a Used Pinball Machine: The Pros & Cons
Buying a used pinball machine for sale can be a smart move. You can save thousands and even snag a rare classic pinball machine that appreciates in value. But be careful— not all used pinball machines are a steal.
Pros of Buying a Used Pinball Machine:
- Cheaper – You can get a solid machine for $2,000-$5,000.
- More variety – Vintage, rare, and discontinued pinball machines for sale are only available used.
- Holds value better – Unlike new machines, some older ones gain value over time.
Cons of Buying a Used Pinball Machine:
- Hidden issues. Some machines have been through heavy use.
- Repairs and maintenance. You might need to replace parts sooner.
- No warranty. Once it’s yours, you’re on your own.
Pro Tip: If you’re new to pinball, buy a used pinball machine from a trusted dealer who refurbishes and guarantees their machines, like High Score Heaven.
Where to Find the Best Pinball for Sale in 2025
Not all pinball sellers are trustworthy.
Scammers take thousands from buyers who get a “deal too good to be true” on eBay or Craigslist, only to realize they just wired money to a ghost.
Here are the best places to find a legitimate pinball for sale.
Best Online Retailers for Pinball Machines for Sale
- High Score Heaven – Verified dealer, warranty, and top-rated selection
- The Pinball Company – Large inventory, but prices can be high
- Marco Specialties – Great for pinball parts and vintage machines
Best Marketplaces for Used Pinball Machines for Sale
- eBay – Good for deals, but beware of fake listings.
- Facebook Marketplace – Local sellers, but inspect before buying.
- Pinside Forum – Best for finding pinball machines from real collectors.
Local Stores and Arcades Selling Pinball Machines
- Check arcades and entertainment venues. Many upgrade machines and sell their older pinball machines.
- Visit High Score Heaven’s Showroom to test your pinball machine before you buy.
Avoid Craigslist unless you meet in person and test the pinball machine.
Top 5 Pinball Machines for Sale in 2025
- Godzilla Pinball (Stern) – Best overall pinball for resale value
- Jurassic Park Pinball – Perfect for home arcades
- Iron Maiden Pinball – A must-have for rock and roll collectors
- Deadpool Pinball – One of the best modern pinball machines
- Attack From Mars (Remake) – Classic pinball at its best
Need help choosing? Contact High Score Heaven for expert recommendations on the best pinball for sale.
How to Avoid Getting Scammed When Buying a Pinball Machine
- If it’s too cheap, it’s probably fake.
- Always ask for a video of the pinball machine working.
- Check the serial number.
- Never send wire transfers to unknown sellers online.
Want a safe purchase? Stick with trusted dealers like High Score Heaven.
How to Maintain Your Pinball Machine and Keep It Valuable
If you want your pinball machine to last and hold its value, follow these maintenance tips:
- Clean the playfield monthly – Dust and dirt wear down parts fast.
- Replace rubber rings and flippers when worn – Improves game performance.
- Keep your pinball machine in a climate-controlled room – Avoid heat and humidity damage.
- Upgrade to LED lighting – Extends the lifespan of your pinball machine.
Pro Tip: A well-maintained pinball machine holds its resale value and sometimes even appreciates over time.
Final Thoughts – Get the Best Pinball for Sale in 2025
If you’re serious about buying a pinball machine, buy smart.
- New vs. Used? Depends on budget and needs.
- Best place to buy? Stick with trusted retailers like High Score Heaven.
- Best pinball machines? Stick with Stern, Bally, and Chicago Gaming remakes.
- Avoid scams. Always verify the seller before paying.
- Keep your machine maintained. It’s an investment.
Ready to buy? Browse our latest pinball machines for sale here.
Have questions? Contact our experts today.
